Yet degrowth is a “model” of transition that deserves its place in democratic debate. Above all, it has serious economic foundations, coupled with a stronger commitment to social justice.

But perhaps we should start by dropping the fairy tales. Degrowth is certainly not a cheerful, simplistic project involving swapping SUVs for electric bikes. Some also suggest defining it as replacing steaks with lentils, or Amazon with the Saturday morning market. Naturally, according to the politicians promoting this version of degrowth, we could do all this without cutting consumption, mobility, social protection, leisure or material comfort too much.

That is simply the ecological transition as told to children. The real question is how to organise a society with less energy, fewer materials and fewer goods.

Because the economy is not an accounting abstraction. Production means extracting resources, using energy, transforming materials and ultimately generating waste. Historically, expanding economic activity has gone hand in hand with enormous increases in physical flows and environmental pressures.

That is precisely the problem in the twenty-first century. The rise of oil at the beginning of the previous century made today’s world possible. We cannot dismiss the advances in certain areas of healthcare, housing and transport enabled by oil and its derivatives. Our growth model was built around oil.

Despite these apparent “advances”, this fossil-fuelled growth model soon revealed its limits. As early as 1972, reports such as the famous The Limits to Growth highlighted the connections between economic growth, ecological pressures and finite resources. Meanwhile, multiple forms of pollution now threaten human health and contribute to the collapse of biodiversity.

Put simply: our almost systematic reliance on fossil fuels is driving us straight into a wall.

Green Growth Does Not Exist

We are told that future growth must be “green”. This is linked to the idea of decoupling, frequently promoted by politicians and industrial businesses. Put simply, decoupling means economic growth, measured by rising GDP, continuing while natural resource consumption and environmental impacts—greenhouse gas emissions, pollution and so on—either decline or increase more slowly. If decoupling is promoted so enthusiastically, it is surely because it allows us to avoid changing anything fundamental: keep producing more while consuming fewer resources. A magnificent lie.

In this model, technology is one way to produce more while causing less damage. You only need to look at the development of artificial intelligence to understand that decoupling will never become a reality without carefully designed, coherent planning. Planning that industrial businesses almost systematically reject, despite their sometimes angelic rhetoric.

And the decoupling we do observe often remains woefully inadequate. The achievements being celebrated are frequently grossly exaggerated. Some sectors can obviously be fully decarbonised. Certain production methods are becoming much more efficient. But these developments do nothing to stop the destruction of the living world, because we relentlessly keep producing more.

And let us be honest: time matters. No economy is reducing its ecological footprint quickly enough. So how can it claim that it can grow indefinitely?

There is also an energy constraint. Oil production is destined to fall sharply by the end of the century, and probably as early as 2050. This decline will either be a deliberate response to climate change or be imposed by physical and geological constraints. Europe, among others, will have to function with fewer hydrocarbons. And let us be serious: electrification can undoubtedly help reduce greenhouse gas emissions and therefore climate impacts. Yet environmental pressures will remain. Electrification means more mines, more extraction, more technology and so on.

Whether you or I support or oppose degrowth is therefore beside the point. The only question that really matters is: “What will we do when it arrives?” Better still: how do we organise it so that we are not simply forced to endure it?

Degrowth Will Not Be a Happy Affair

If we genuinely produce less, many activities will have to shrink substantially, while others will disappear. Jobs will go with them.

We cannot argue that we must drastically reduce air travel, fast fashion, advertising, heavy cars, certain energy-intensive leisure activities, the constant replacement of possessions and compulsive consumption—and promise that nobody’s life will be turned upside down.

Advertising itself raises an almost comical question: why preserve a gigantic industry whose purpose partly consists of persuading us to consume more, in a society trying to consume less?

A post-growth economy will therefore have to dispense with much of this constant encouragement to buy.

Industrial restructuring, in particular, will be extensive. And we will probably need to work differently, perhaps even less, rather than manufacture needs to keep jobs artificially alive.

The Social Model Will Have to Be Rethought

Here is a subject nobody is particularly keen to discuss. Especially in France!

Pension systems, healthcare, education and redistribution expanded considerably during a period of strong growth. Growth clearly made it easier to fund hospitals, education and a degree of wealth-sharing.

But it is dishonest to promise a lasting reduction in material production while guaranteeing that every existing social mechanism will remain completely unchanged. Some established entitlements will have to be redefined, whether we like it or not. Politicians will have to prioritise spending, redirect it or even abandon some of it.

Once again, a whole series of collective and individual choices must be made, urgently. Degrowth forces us to choose. That is precisely what Western societies hate doing. But accepting this reality certainly does not mean imposing austerity on the poor while the rich keep collecting air miles and second homes. We can at least insist on that!

A society with less material wealth that remained profoundly unequal would quickly become explosive.

Degrowth is therefore acceptable only if it comes with much greater redistribution. Planned reductions in production and consumption, social justice and quality of life must be its foundations. Broad protection for whatever we define as essential must be guaranteed. Conversely, the superfluous will gradually be phased out or penalised.

Another obvious requirement is that those who own and consume the most must contribute proportionately much more. They are also often the people who hold power. So we can safely assume that they will object and resist. Yet there is no alternative: no degrowth without genuine social justice.

You can see the point: degrowth is not merely an environmental programme. It fundamentally challenges the Western social contract. In France, putting it into practice is even more complicated because that social contract underpins our model of society. Any reform will therefore affect large numbers of people, often among the most vulnerable.

You will also have understood that the “growth versus degrowth” debate is sterile. What we should actually be debating is planned, democratically discussed and redistributive degrowth versus contraction imposed through a succession of crises. Whatever we decide, degrowth will come. If the current system persists through deliberate choice, inaction or inertia, the world will inevitably face successive energy, industrial, economic, social, insurance and ecological crises. And it will not withstand them.

Living or Surviving

There is nevertheless something rather strange about systematically presenting this transformation as a catastrophe. In Europe, we will lose some of what we currently call comfort. That much is obvious. Resilience without excessive reliance on technology is not our strong suit. Other civilisations will cope much better because they currently enjoy far less material comfort, but also because their relationship with the living world is very different. We will therefore have to give up some journeys, consume less, own less, produce fewer entirely dispensable things and seriously rethink our relationship with work.

But does that necessarily mean living worse? A society that placed greater value on health, free time, human relationships, social justice, environmental quality or simply the protection of the living world would not necessarily be a backward-looking society. Today, improving our lives is tied to constantly increasing what we produce and consume. If losing a few points of growth allows us to gain elsewhere, then let us collectively take that risk. Now.